What is holistic admissions in college applications?

Holistic admissions offer a comprehensive approach to college applications, moving beyond mere grades and test scores. This process evaluates applicants on various factors, including extracurricular involvement, personal essays, recommendation letters, leadership roles, and life experiences. Colleges using this method seek to understand the applicant as a whole person, assessing their character, passions, and potential for growth. By considering a broader range of attributes, institutions aim to create a diverse student body with unique perspectives and talents. This approach acknowledges that academic metrics alone may not fully reflect an individual's capabilities or potential contributions to the college community.

How can I stand out in the holistic admissions process?

To excel in holistic admissions, applicants should spotlight their unique narratives, leadership abilities, and personal evolution. Compelling personal statements, meaningful extracurricular involvement, and recommendation letters that underscore character are paramount. Genuine authenticity is essential; colleges aim to perceive the individual beyond their academic transcripts. This means showcasing not just accomplishments but also the values, passions, and experiences that shape who you are. By emphasizing these personal aspects, students can craft a more vivid and memorable application that resonates with admissions officers seeking to build a diverse and dynamic student body.

Do test-optional colleges still consider SAT/ACT scores in holistic admissions?

Yes, test-optional colleges may still consider SAT/ACT scores if you submit them, but they are not required. In holistic admissions, schools place more emphasis on your academic rigor, personal essays, extracurricular achievements, and other elements that reflect your potential and character. Even though a college is test-optional, submitting strong scores can still supplement your application. However, a lack of scores won't automatically disqualify you. The focus shifts to a broader evaluation, considering how all aspects of your application, including personal narratives and accomplishments, demonstrate your suitability for the institution. Test-optional policies provide flexibility but don't assume scores are irrelevant if submitted.

What matters more in holistic admissions: GPA or extracurricular activities?

In holistic admissions, both GPA and extracurricular activities are important, and colleges seek a balance between them. GPA demonstrates academic ability and the capacity to handle coursework, while extracurricular activities showcase leadership, passion, and practical skills. Though strong grades are valued, impactful and consistent involvement in extracurriculars can sometimes compensate for a less-than-perfect GPA. Colleges look beyond just academic achievements, considering the whole person and what they can contribute to the campus community. Ultimately, a compelling narrative highlighting academic competence and personal growth through extracurricular involvement is your edge to a successful application.

What Holistic Admissions Really Means for Today’s Applicants

Getting into college used to be all about numbers—GPA, SAT scores, class rank. If your stats were high enough, you were in. If not, tough luck. But those days are fading fast. Today, college admissions are less about checking boxes and more about understanding who you are as a person.

This change is the result of holistic admissions, which takes into account your interests, difficulties, and potential in addition to test results to look at the big picture. It’s definitely a game-changer, particularly for kids who may not have an impeccable GPA but have something unique to offer.

But what does this really mean for you? How do you stand out in a process that’s, well, so broad? Let’s break it down.

Why Holistic Admissions Exist in the First Place

For decades, college admissions were painfully predictable. If you had great scores, you had a shot. If you didn’t, your chances were slim. Then colleges started asking a simple but powerful question: Do test scores and grades really tell us everything about a student’s potential?

The answer’s a resounding no.

Holistic admissions started taking over. Schools wanted to admit students who weren’t just book-smart but also innovative, resilient, and capable of making an impact.

Fast forward to today, and holistic admissions are the norm, especially at top schools. And with the rise of test-optional policies, students now have more ways than ever to show what they bring to the table.

What Actually Matters in a Holistic Application?

So, if colleges aren’t just looking at numbers, what are they looking at? Here’s the inside scoop:

Your Academic Performance Still Matters—But They’re Not Everything

Let’s be real—grades and course rigor still play a role. Colleges want to know how you can handle their coursework. But if your GPA isn’t perfect, don’t panic. Schools also consider growth and improvement. A strong upward trend can sometimes speak louder than a perfect 4.0.

The Power of Personal Stories in College Admissions Essays

Ever wondered why colleges make you write essays? It’s because they want to hear your story—what drives you or what gets you out of bed in the morning, the challenges you’ve faced and how you overcame them.

Maybe you spent years taking care of younger siblings while balancing school and a job. Maybe you started a small business, or maybe you overcame a learning disability. Whatever it is, own it.

Essays aren’t just about good writing; they’re about authenticity. Admissions officers can tell when someone is trying too hard to sound impressive. Instead of listing achievements, show them who you are.

Extracurriculars: Quality Over Quantity

Forget the myth that you need to be in 20 clubs to impress colleges. Admissions officers don’t care about long lists—they care about impact.

Did you lead a club? Start a nonprofit? Win awards for your art or music? Stick with a few meaningful activities and show depth, leadership, and passion.

Why Character and Resilience Matter in College Applications

Colleges love students who can handle setbacks. Life isn’t perfect, and neither is college. Schools want to know how you deal with failure, bounce back from challenges, and push through tough times.

This can come through in your essays, letters of recommendation, or even how you frame a low grade or bad semester. Growth matters more than perfection.

Demonstrated Interest: Does It Really Help Your College Application?

Some schools track whether you’ve visited campus, attended virtual sessions, or emailed admissions officers. Showing genuine interest can help your chances, but only if it’s authentic. Don’t force it—just be engaged if you’re truly excited about a school.

The Growing Importance of Holistic Admissions in 2025 and Beyond

Beyond just making admissions more fair, holistic review is also a response to something bigger: the “enrollment cliff.”

Fewer students are applying to college, and schools are getting nervous. To stay competitive, they need to attract a more diverse range of students, including those who might have been overlooked in the old system.

This means holistic admissions aren’t going anywhere. In fact, they’ll probably become even more important in the coming years.

How to Stand Out in a Holistic Admissions Process

Now that you know what colleges are looking for, here’s how to use holistic admissions to your advantage:

Tell a compelling story. Your personal statement isn’t just another essay—it’s your chance to be memorable. Make it count.
Focus on impact, not just involvement. A leadership role in one club is better than passive membership in ten.
Emphasize resilience. If you’ve overcome challenges, don’t hide them. Show how they’ve shaped you.
Get strong letters of recommendation. Build relationships with teachers who know you well and can vouch for your character.
Be authentic. Don’t write what you think colleges want to hear. Be you—that’s what they’re looking for.

Why This is Good News for Applicants

Although there isn’t a single recipe for success, you have more influence over your story with this holistic approach.

This is a game-changer for kids who have put in a lot of effort but don’t have a flawless academic record. It indicates that universities are considering more than simply your test-taking skills. Instead of being defined by a test score, you get to showcase your passions, your growth, and the qualities that make you uniquely you.

Like what you see here? We are happy to permit you to use our material as long as you link back! Please refer to us as the Cardinal Education Blog.

Call us today to learn more about our admissions consulting.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is holistic admissions in college applications?
Holistic admissions offer a comprehensive approach to college applications, moving beyond mere grades and test scores. This process evaluates applicants on various factors, including extracurricular involvement, personal essays, recommendation letters, leadership roles, and life experiences. Colleges using this method seek to understand the applicant as a whole person, assessing their character, passions, and potential for growth. By considering a broader range of attributes, institutions aim to create a diverse student body with unique perspectives and talents. This approach acknowledges that academic metrics alone may not fully reflect an individual’s capabilities or potential contributions to the college community.
How can I stand out in the holistic admissions process?
To excel in holistic admissions, applicants should spotlight their unique narratives, leadership abilities, and personal evolution. Compelling personal statements, meaningful extracurricular involvement, and recommendation letters that underscore character are paramount. Genuine authenticity is essential; colleges aim to perceive the individual beyond their academic transcripts. This means showcasing not just accomplishments but also the values, passions, and experiences that shape who you are. By emphasizing these personal aspects, students can craft a more vivid and memorable application that resonates with admissions officers seeking to build a diverse and dynamic student body.
Do test-optional colleges still consider SAT/ACT scores in holistic admissions?
Yes, test-optional colleges may still consider SAT/ACT scores if you submit them, but they are not required. In holistic admissions, schools place more emphasis on your academic rigor, personal essays, extracurricular achievements, and other elements that reflect your potential and character. Even though a college is test-optional, submitting strong scores can still supplement your application. However, a lack of scores won’t automatically disqualify you. The focus shifts to a broader evaluation, considering how all aspects of your application, including personal narratives and accomplishments, demonstrate your suitability for the institution. Test-optional policies provide flexibility but don’t assume scores are irrelevant if submitted.
What matters more in holistic admissions: GPA or extracurricular activities?
In holistic admissions, both GPA and extracurricular activities are important, and colleges seek a balance between them. GPA demonstrates academic ability and the capacity to handle coursework, while extracurricular activities showcase leadership, passion, and practical skills. Though strong grades are valued, impactful and consistent involvement in extracurriculars can sometimes compensate for a less-than-perfect GPA. Colleges look beyond just academic achievements, considering the whole person and what they can contribute to the campus community. Ultimately, a compelling narrative highlighting academic competence and personal growth through extracurricular involvement is your edge to a successful application.