Deadlines, essays, and decisions pile up quickly during college applications. One of the most important choices you’ll face early on is deciding which application timeline works best for you: Early Action (EA), Early Decision (ED), or Regular Decision (RD). We’ll break down these rounds to help you figure out which option works best for your situation.
College goals and preferences differ for every applicant, so various application rounds exist to cater to the applicants’ needs. However, each has pros and cons, which we will also tackle in this blog. If your goal is to attend top-tier schools, we want you to make the right decision based on your personal, academic, and financial goals and make the best shot.
Keep reading to learn how to make the most of these opportunities!
1. Early Action (EA)
EA means you can apply and receive your admissions decision earlier than RD applicants, usually in December. EA is nonbinding, so you’re not in any way required to commit to the school if accepted. EA schools like the University of Michigan also report slightly higher acceptance rates for early applicants.
Students who feel confident about their application materials by the early fall and those who want to maximize options but need more time to make a final decision are the ideal candidates for this application.
| Pros | Cons |
| Higher acceptance rates | Less time to perfect essays |
| More time to evaluate options | Lesser chances of improving test scores |
| Less stress later | Limited ability to apply early to multiple schools if Restrictive Early Action (REA) policies apply |
Note: Schools like Stanford, Yale, and Harvard offer REA programs, prohibiting you from applying EA to other private institutions. It’s always best to check the specific policies of each school.
2. Early Decision (ED)
ED, unlike EA, is a binding agreement, which means you are bound to their school once accepted. Simply put, if you’re admitted, you’re required to attend and must withdraw all other applications. Decisions are typically released in mid-December.
Students with a clear first-choice school and no financial constraints are ideal candidates. Make sure to have researched schools early and ensure that the school’s philosophy, academic programs, and policies match your educational, social, and financial needs.
| Pros | Cons |
| Significantly higher acceptance rates | No financial aid comparisons |
| Simplified process | Pressure to decide early |
ED schools like Cornell, Northwestern, Duke, and Penn fill over half of their incoming class through ED. Applying ED shows a strong commitment, which means you’re all in. This can give your application a competitive edge. Moreover, if accepted, you can focus on preparing early for college instead of juggling multiple applications.
On the other hand, you’re locked into attending even if other schools might offer better aid packages, including financial assistance. The binding nature of ED can feel restrictive, especially if your goals or priorities change.
ED can be an incredible opportunity, but only if you’re 100% certain. Research shows that ED applicants have college acceptance rates 1.5-2x higher than RD applicants at some competitive schools—but this boost only matters if you’re genuinely interested and ready.
3. Regular Decision (RD)
Regular Decision is the traditional application route, with deadlines in January or February and decisions released in Spring (March or April).
Students who need more time to refine their applications or still want to improve their grades or test scores are ideal candidates. They may also want to compare offers and evaluate financial aid packages.
| Pros | Cons |
| Flexibility to perfect your application | Increased competition |
| Opportunity to apply broadly | Later timeline |
RD is the traditional application route, with deadlines in January or February and decisions released in spring, either in March or April.
Students who need additional time to polish their applications or still want to improve their grades or test scores best apply to this round. They may also want to compare offers and evaluate financial aid packages.
Am I ready?
If your essays, test scores, and grades are strong by November, EA or ED may be the right school. If not, RD gives you more time to prepare.
Is there a clear first-choice school?
If one school stands out above the rest, ED might be the best path—but only if you’ve done thorough research and are comfortable with the financial commitment.
Do I need financial flexibility?
If comparing aid packages is essential, EA or RD may better suit you than ED. If finances are a concern, remember that ED limits your ability to shop around for the best aid package.
Am I willing to take on a more competitive pool?
RD applicants often face tougher competition since fewer spots are available after EA and ED rounds.
The Cardinal Education Approach: Strategic Insights on Applications
Our team of expert counselors at Cardinal Education has guided countless students through the college admissions process, and one thing is certain: the decision to apply to EA, ED, and RD is also about strategy, preparation, and self-awareness. While the allure of higher acceptance rates is real, the choice depends on your situation.
EA Strategy
Early Action is one of the most flexible and strategic options available. We encourage EA applicants to prioritize schools where their profile matches the institutional priorities, such as test scores, academic rigor, or extracurricular impact. While EA isn’t binding, schools still want to see genuine interest. Demonstrating why a school is the right fit for you is critical in the early rounds. Many schools measure your interest through their demonstrated letter of interest, and our admissions counselors can help you articulate your interest in these schools.
ED Strategy
Colleges love ED applicants because they signal commitment, which simplifies enrollment planning. At Cardinal, we’ve seen ED significantly boost acceptance odds for students ready to make that leap of faith.
But here’s the catch: ED works best for students with a crystal-clear first choice. Without that clarity, the binding nature of ED can lead to regrets, especially if financial considerations come into play. We work closely with families to assess not just academic fit but also financial feasibility, ensuring our students are making informed decisions.
RD Strategy
At Cardinal, we remind our students that RD doesn’t mean “less strategic.” By the time RD rolls around, schools are looking to fill specific gaps in their incoming class. Tailoring your application to meet those needs—whether it’s emphasizing a unique extracurricular or showcasing leadership—is key to standing out.
Our Takeaway for Families
At Cardinal Education, we ensure that your decision maximizes your acceptance rates and that the school you choose aligns with your goals, values, and financial situation. We’re here to guide you through the nuances of the admissions process, helping you strategize while incorporating your most authentic self into your application.
Remember: The right timeline isn’t just about the numbers; it’s about finding the place where you’ll thrive. If you’re still unsure about which path to take, let’s have a conversation. At Cardinal Education, we don’t just help students get in—we help them find the schools that feel like home.
Like what you see here? We are happy to permit you to use our material as long as you link back! Please refer to us as the Cardinal Education Blog.
If you want additional time and flexibility, EA might be the better choice. But if you’re certain about one school and ready to commit, ED could be a great option.
Contact us today to learn more about our admissions consulting.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can I apply to more than one college under ED?
No, you can’t. To be clear, Early Decision (ED) is binding, which means you can only apply to a single college using this option during the early application period. Once accepted, you’re automatically required to attend that school and withdraw your applications to other colleges.
Fortunately, some colleges provide an Early Decision II (ED II) option, giving you another chance to apply early decision to a different school once rejected to your first-choice ED application. So, if you’re interested in two schools with different ED rounds, you could apply to one in ED I and the other in ED II.
- What happens if I get rejected from your ED/EA school?
Getting rejected from ED/EA can be discouraging, and it’s understandable, but it’s not the end of the world! Remember: you are not rejected because you don’t have potential or lack the abilities, but think of it: that particular school wasn’t the right fit during that application cycle.
The good news? You still have time to apply during the regular decision round. You can take this time to refine your college list and explore options that might be a better academic, social, or financial match for you.
College admissions are about finding the best fit, not just getting into one specific school. So take a deep breath, regroup, and keep going!
- Is Early Decision the right choice for me?
Early Decision is not for everyone. It will be a big leap since you agree and commit to attending the school if accepted. Ask yourself:
- Am I 100% sure this is my top choice?
- Can my family afford the cost without comparing financial aid offers from other schools?
Early Decision might not be the best option if you’re unsure about either. You could consider Early Action (non-binding) or Regular Decision, which gives you more flexibility and time to explore multiple schools.
The goal is to choose the application plan that best suits your needs. Take your time, weigh your options, and choose the path that feels right!
- What’s the difference between Early Decision and Early Action?
Early Decision (ED) is binding, so if you’re accepted, you are required to attend that particular college. It is ideal for students who are 100% sure about their top choice.
On the other hand, early Action (EA) is non-binding, so you can apply early but still be free to consider offers from different colleges. EA allows you to explore other colleges while still getting your decisions earlier than regular applicants.
